French language Q&A Forum
Questions answered by our learning community with help from expert French teachers
14,222 questions • 30,837 answers • 906,826 learners
Questions answered by our learning community with help from expert French teachers
14,222 questions • 30,837 answers • 906,826 learners
I am confused by this example:
"I haven't left France for three years:" "Je n'ai pas quitté la France depuis trois ans."
The lesson says "we use PC because the negation indicates the action wasn't done during the entirety of that past period. BUT PC is used to express actions which were completed or finished in the past.
This example shows it WAS NOT completed, so why PC and not imparfait??
Thank you.
The audio for the complete exercise has some sections missing
vous seriez surprise(you would be surprised) ils auraient de la chance(they would be lucky.
Both are saying "would be" when to use "seriez" and when to use auriez. Because they both are coming from etre and avoir,
Any clarification or any clue will help.
The exercise gave two possibilities: passer prendre et venir chercher. My dictionary adds aller chercher, which is what I chose. Is this not a possibility? Is it a question of perspective in this case? The speaker is the one being picked up, hence venir. If the speaker was asking what time he should pick someone up, then perhaps aller is preferred over venir.
The listing of all of the cases can mislead people that may not have done previous lessons; either assume people know the difference between qui and que and cut out the listing or assume they don't and shine a light on:
(Tout ce) qui = Subject of the following verb
(Tout ce) que = Object of the following verb
The vernacular usage for "vers" with time appears to drop the determinate. This doesn't appear to be true for the other usages of "vers".
In the conditional phrase in the second sentence, we have "...si je ne voulais pas être père...". I have terrible hearing, but I thought I heard d'être père. I know that vouloir does not take a preposition to introduce an infinitive, so I was dubious. I certainly did not hear an elision of the 's' of pas with être. Are my ears deceiving me?
hi,
can someone tell me or give me a link for compound adjective. for example there is a sentence un etonnement bon film and i am just trying to understand the complement of it.
thank you
Find your French level for FREE
Test your French to the CEFR standard
Find your French level