When to use "devoir" in L'Imparfait or Le Passé Composé

The verb devoir usually means must / to have to (see Conjugate devoir in Le Présent (present tense)).

However, in past context, its meaning changes depending on whether you use Passé composé or Imparfait.

Devoir in ImparfaitI was supposed to [do]

Il devait me rappeler, mais il a oublié !
He was supposed to call me back, but he forgot!

Ils devaient venir ce soir, mais ils ont annulé à la dernière minute.
They were supposed to come tonight, but they cancelled at the last minute.

Nous devions nous rejoindre à 17h. Qu'est-ce qui s'est passé ?
We were supposed to meet at 5pm. What happened ?

Maintenant que ses parents n'étaient plus là, elle devait s'occuper de sa sœur.
Now that her parents were gone, she had to take care of her sister.

-> Here we don't know if she fulfilled that obligation.

When conjugated in Imparfaitdevoir refers to a past obligation, without specifying whether it was met or not.
Actually, in most cases, the obligation was not met.

To conjugate devoir in Imparfait, see Conjugate regular verbs in L'Imparfait (imperfect tense)

Devoir in Passé composéI had to [do] / I must have [done]

Il est parti tôt, donc j'ai dû faire la lessive moi-même.
He left early, so I had to do the laundry myself.

Nous étions en retard, donc nous avons dû appeler un taxi.
We were late, so we had to call a taxi.

Il a dû le laisser là pour toi.
He must have left it there for you.

J'ai trouvé l'écharpe de Sophie. Elle a dû l'oublier.
I found Sophie's scarf. She must have forgotten it.

When conjugated in Passé composédevoir can either refer to:
- a past obligation that was met.
or
- the likeliness of an action having taken place, a hypothesis on a past situation.

To conjugate devoir in Passé composé, see Conjugate voir, devoir, pouvoir, boire, croire, savoir, lire, taire (+ avoir) in Le Passé Composé (conversational past)

Learn more about these related French grammar topics

Examples and resources

Ils devaient venir ce soir, mais ils ont annulé à la dernière minute.
They were supposed to come tonight, but they cancelled at the last minute.


Maintenant que ses parents n'étaient plus là, elle devait s'occuper de sa sœur.
Now that her parents were gone, she had to take care of her sister.


Il est parti tôt, donc j'ai dû faire la lessive moi-même.
He left early, so I had to do the laundry myself.


Nous devions nous rejoindre à 17h. Qu'est-ce qui s'est passé ?
We were supposed to meet at 5pm. What happened ?


Il a dû le laisser là pour toi.
He must have left it there for you.


Nous étions en retard, donc nous avons dû appeler un taxi.
We were late, so we had to call a taxi.


Il devait me rappeler, mais il a oublié !
He was supposed to call me back, but he forgot!


J'ai trouvé l'écharpe de Sophie. Elle a dû l'oublier.
I found Sophie's scarf. She must have forgotten it.


Q&A Forum 7 questions, 11 answers

SamA1Kwiziq community member

Elle a dû oublier de t'appeler. Why is there a "de" between oublier and t'appeler?

Elle a dû oublier de t'appeler.


Hello why is there a "de" between oublier and t'appeler?

I often see a "de" in sentences whose placement I can't really understand. I would like to know if there is a rule for this.

Asked 2 weeks ago
CécileKwiziq team memberCorrect answer

Hi Sam,

There are lots of verbs in French which (when they are followed by another verb) have to have the preposition 'de' or  'à' before the second verb in the infinitive.

I am working on some study lists for such verbs which you can look out for in the future.

In the meantime, here are a few -

Oublier de [faire] = To forget [to do something]

Accepter de [faire] = To accept [to do something] 

Choisir de [faire] To choose [to do something]

Arrêter de [faire] To stop [doing something]

etc.

Hope this helps!

JamesonB1Kwiziq Q&A regular contributor

And just to add a bit of rascally (but correct) excess to the great answer by Cecile, I will add, please  remember that this odd looking *de* occurrence does not only appear between two verbs.

 Or as Cecile may say in french at the end of her list..

 "Vous devez vous souvenir de ca"/ You have to  remember that!... which to me is one of the funniest occurrences of 'de' and hard to get your mind around  but cool once learnt.

Good luck from one learner to another!

CécileKwiziq team member

Very interesting comment, Jameson, we natives don't always see the problems you encounter and this is one which would have eluded me...

Elle a dû oublier de t'appeler. Why is there a "de" between oublier and t'appeler?

Elle a dû oublier de t'appeler.


Hello why is there a "de" between oublier and t'appeler?

I often see a "de" in sentences whose placement I can't really understand. I would like to know if there is a rule for this.

Sign in to submit your answer

Don't have an account yet? Join today

DiegoB1Kwiziq Q&A regular contributor

il a oublié?

Il devait me rappeler, mais il a oublié !


Should this be "il l'a oublié"? It sounds weird without a direct object for oublier.

Asked 4 weeks ago
CécileKwiziq team memberCorrect answer

Hi Diego,

It is correct to say -

Il a oublié ( de me rappeler) as in English,= He has forgotten ( to call me back )

'Il l'a oublié' would refer to an object like a tablet, a phone, a book ...

e.g.

Son passeport? Il l'a oublié, il est dans son tiroir His passport? he has forgotten it, it is in his drawer

Hope this helps!

il a oublié?

Il devait me rappeler, mais il a oublié !


Should this be "il l'a oublié"? It sounds weird without a direct object for oublier.

Sign in to submit your answer

Don't have an account yet? Join today

JoanneB2Kwiziq community member

de retard vs. du retard

Although this was an exercise about using "devoir", I didn't understand how it expressed "to be late," which was son train a eu du retard Shouldn't it be "de retard" not "du retard?"

Asked 4 months ago
CécileKwiziq team memberCorrect answer

Hi Joanne,

The expression is -

‘Avoir du retard’ = To be late /delayed

L’avion que nous attendons a du retard = The plane we are waiting for is late/delayed 

J’ai beaucoup de retard il faut que je me dépêche = I am very late I must hurry

Hope this helps!

de retard vs. du retard

Although this was an exercise about using "devoir", I didn't understand how it expressed "to be late," which was son train a eu du retard Shouldn't it be "de retard" not "du retard?"

Sign in to submit your answer

Don't have an account yet? Join today

TedC1Kwiziq community member

l'imparfait de devoir

I am assuming that "was supposed to" and "ought to have" are the same: "he ought to have reminded me"/"he was supposed to remind me" = "il devrait me rappeler".

Asked 5 months ago
CécileKwiziq team memberCorrect answer

Hi Ted,

'was supposed' would use devoir in the imparfait as it is the past -

Il devait me contacter mais ne l'a pas fait = He was supposed to contact me but didn't do it

Il devait me rappeler He was supposed to remind me /to call me back

'ought to' would use devoir in the conditional ( something that should happen)

Elle devrait aller voir ses parents plus souvent = She ought to go and visit her parents more often

'ought to have' would use devoir in the conditional past (something that should have happened but it's in the past so won't happen now)

Ils auraient dû me demander de les aider They ought to have asked me to help them

Three different ideas and three different tenses, same verb.

But very good question!

Hope this helps!

l'imparfait de devoir

I am assuming that "was supposed to" and "ought to have" are the same: "he ought to have reminded me"/"he was supposed to remind me" = "il devrait me rappeler".

Sign in to submit your answer

Don't have an account yet? Join today

William C1Kwiziq Q&A regular contributor

A Supplementary Question

I know that the exercise is about conjugating "devoir" but the second clause is unusual.

You were supposed to go and see her, but something came up. Will there be an separate exercise for this construction?

 ".... but something came up"   .... " ..... mais tu as eu un empéchement"

Asked 11 months ago
CécileKwiziq team memberCorrect answer

Hi William,

'Avoir un empêchement' means to, have an obstruction, hindrance that stopped you doing something ...

So it can be translated in English by

' to have an emergency''to be unable to do something', or 'something came up' as in the example you quote.

Hope this helps!

 

William C1Kwiziq Q&A regular contributor

Is "mais elle a eu un empéchement" also possible here? 

CécileKwiziq team member

Tout à fait, William ...

A Supplementary Question

I know that the exercise is about conjugating "devoir" but the second clause is unusual.

You were supposed to go and see her, but something came up. Will there be an separate exercise for this construction?

 ".... but something came up"   .... " ..... mais tu as eu un empéchement"

Sign in to submit your answer

Don't have an account yet? Join today

AnnC1Kwiziq Q&A regular contributor

The way I understand devoir, it can mean inevitability in the imparfait such as Il eva it perdre un jour. in the test question, the answer for she had

to replace him was "Elle a dû" vs if it was inevitable, shouldn't "Elle devait" be correct as well?

Asked 1 year ago
ChrisC1 Kwiziq Q&A super contributor

Elle a dû le remplacer. -- She had to replace him.Elle devait le remplacer. -- She was supposed to replace him.

AnnC1Kwiziq Q&A regular contributor

From the thought co: You can also use devoir to express fatalism or the fact that something is inevitable:

Il devait perdre un jour. > He had to / was bound to lose one day. Elle ne devait pas l'entendre avant lundi. > She wasn't to hear it until Monday.

The way I understand devoir, it can mean inevitability in the imparfait such as Il eva it perdre un jour. in the test question, the answer for she had

to replace him was "Elle a dû" vs if it was inevitable, shouldn't "Elle devait" be correct as well?

Sign in to submit your answer

Don't have an account yet? Join today

BillC1Kwiziq Q&A regular contributor

New lesson

Great lesson but didn’t see it til I failed a test question:(. Is there a way to find new lessons easily if one has already gotten 100% on all existing lessons? Merci

Asked 1 year ago

New lesson

Great lesson but didn’t see it til I failed a test question:(. Is there a way to find new lessons easily if one has already gotten 100% on all existing lessons? Merci

Sign in to submit your answer

Don't have an account yet? Join today

Let me take a look at that...