You define L'imparfait as being about things that happened repeatedly in the past or past habits. Yet "You had eaten cereal this morning" is neither a repeated action nor a past habits, yet is expressed in L'imparfait... "tu avais mangé des céréales ce matin"? Sounds more like your definition of le passé composé - a single event in a defined timeframe. I get that the grammar is correct. What I'm questioning is your definitions.
"You had" + verb is l'imparfait?
- « Back to Q&A Forum
- « Previous questionNext question »
"You had" + verb is l'imparfait?
It seems likely you have come across this sentence in another lesson or context?
Tu mangeais des céreales ce matin ... You were eating cereal this morning (when I saw you, or whatever) - Imparfait
Tu as mangé des céreales ce matin ... You ate cereal this morning. - Passé Composé
Tu avais mangé des céréales ce matin - You had eaten cereal this morning . . . (before you went out, or whatever) - Plus-que-parfait
Hi Gilberts,
I assume that you are referring to question 2 at the end of the lesson?
"You had eaten ...." is an option for you to select.
The user has to decide whether that expression meets the lesson criteria or not?
I will refrain from answering for you -- that would defeat the object of the lesson.
Bonne continuation.
Jim
"You had eaten" is past perfect tense, not imperfect.
"You ate" is imperfect tense.
Don't have an account yet? Join today
Find your French level for FREE
Test your French to the CEFR standard
Find your French level