Dans la phrase, "N'ajoute aucun ingrédient qui nuirait à l'équilibre du plat, quelle que soit son originalité ou sa rareté.", le mot ’quelle’ fait référence à quoi ? Ingrédient ( aucun agrément), originalité ? Merce de votre explication en avance.
Question about agreement
- « Back to Q&A Forum
- « Previous questionNext question »
Question about agreement
Frank,
"N'ajoute aucun ingrédient qui nuirait à l'équilibre du plat, quelle que soit son originalité ou sa rareté."
The agreement of ‘ quel (que soit) noun ‘ is with the noun/s it relates to - that is the subject of ‘ soit ‘ .
This is a ‘ compound conjunction ‘ - the subject follows the verb and in this sentence the subject is ‘ son originalité ‘ or ‘ sa rareté ‘ - both feminine singular.
The indefinite adjective ‘ quel ‘ follows the normal rules of adjectival agreement with the noun.
There is effectively only 1 subject at a time with the use of ‘ ou ‘, giving rise to the use of the feminine singular ‘ quelle ‘ in the expression, as both are grammatically feminine singular.
What if the compound subject consisted of a feminine noun and a masculine noun ? Would we then use quel ?
Frank,
The normal rules of agreement apply, so, yes, in French that means a mixed gender choice results in use of the masculine form. This applies regardless of the order of the nouns in the phrase.
So if you had, for example “ son originalité ou son prestige “ (feminine singular + masculine singular)
you would use ‘ quel que soit son originalité ou son prestige. ‘
Don't have an account yet? Join today
Find your French level for FREE
Test your French to the CEFR standard
Find your French level