Les garçons ont passé leur examen et tous l'ont eu.

DanielA2

Les garçons ont passé leur examen et tous l'ont eu.

isn't it the other way around? Les garçons ont eu leur examen et tous l'ont passé.
Asked 1 year ago
CécileKwiziq language super starCorrect answer

Hi Daniel,

As Chris says,  in French,

passer un examen, means to take an exam and

avoir un examen means to have passed it

 It is what we call a faux-ami ( false friend or false cognate) you think it means the same in English but this is not the case. You will meet quite a few of those as you are learning.

To give another example , compare ,

Il passe son permis de conduire demain . ( He is taking his driving test tomorrow )

and

Ça y est ! il a son permis ( de conduire) , That's it ! He's passed his driving licence.

Hope this helps!

Well, no, actually. Passer un examen -- to take an exam (not necessarily tompass it). Avoir un examen -- to pass it. This is confusing because in English it seems to be zhe other way round. -- Chris (not a native speaker) P.S.: I have been told, however, that this distinction is lost on many native French speakers.
Daniel asked:View original

Les garçons ont passé leur examen et tous l'ont eu.

isn't it the other way around? Les garçons ont eu leur examen et tous l'ont passé.

Sign in to submit your answer

Don't have an account yet? Join today

Find your French level for FREE

Test your French to the CEFR standard

Find your French level >>
Ask a question
How has your day been?