Incorrect answer

Richard S.C1Kwiziq community member

Incorrect answer

"Nous avons mangé en une heure" does not have a correct answer.  "We ate in an hour" and "We ate in an hour´s time" are both incorrect.  An appropriate answer would be "We ate for an hour."  (American English)

Asked 1 day ago
Anne D.C1 Kwiziq Q&A super contributor Correct answer

No expert, but my understanding of "en" is that it expresses the time frame within which something happens, the time it took - we weren’t necessarily eating for the whole hour. "In an hour" seems a good rendering (UK English) of "en une heure" for events in the past. Whereas "dans une heure" is looking forward to a future event and can usually translate as "in an hour’s time" as well as "in an hour".

 

However I do find "within an hour" is used confusingly in this lesson and discussion, as "within" implies to me the time by which something happens (="d’ici une heure"). 

 

Maarten K.C1 Kwiziq Q&A super contributor Correct answer

To add to Anne’s response,

The question noted is a copy of one of the examples in the lesson, with only a change from 40 minutes to 1 hour. 

The lesson example is translated to ‘ We ate in 40 minutes ‘. Not as precise as it could be, but standard everyday English, at least in some parts of the English-speaking world. 

This translation to English reflects the original French meaning of ‘ nous avons mangé en 40 minutes ‘  - a sentence which does not necessarily imply eating (constantly) for 40 minutes.

‘ Nous avons mangé (pendant) 40 minutes ‘ would be ‘ we ate for 40 minutes ‘.

 Expressing for + [duration] in French with either pendant/durant/depuis/pour (French Prepositions of Time)

Richard S. asked:

Incorrect answer

"Nous avons mangé en une heure" does not have a correct answer.  "We ate in an hour" and "We ate in an hour´s time" are both incorrect.  An appropriate answer would be "We ate for an hour."  (American English)

Sign in to submit your answer

Don't have an account yet? Join today

Ask a question

Find your French level for FREE

Test your French to the CEFR standard

Find your French level
Getting that for you now...