Elles auraient eu un chien si elles avaient pu. Why is it "elles avaient pu " and not " elles auraient pu " Is this not a 'Past conditional "

Lee H.C1Kwiziq community member

Elles auraient eu un chien si elles avaient pu. Why is it "elles avaient pu " and not " elles auraient pu " Is this not a 'Past conditional "

 Is this phrase  not a   'Past conditional " structure?

Asked 5 years ago
Chris W.C1 Kwiziq Q&A super contributor Correct answer

In a standard "si"-clause, the conditional is in the main clause of the sentence.

The three versions of the conditional clause are:

If I can, I'll buy a car. -- Si je peux, j'achèterai une voiture. Si clause: present tense -- main clause: future tense (or present tense)

If I were rich, I would by a car. -- Si j'étais riche, j'acheterais une voiture.Si clause: imparfait -- main clause: present conditional

If I had been rich, I would have bought a car. -- Si j'avais été riche, j'aurais acheté une voiture.Si clause: plusqueparfait -- main clause: past conditional

If you look at the English versions, they actually follow the French!

CécileNative French expert teacher in KwiziqCorrect answer

Hi Lee,

Si j'avais vu votre question, j'aurais répondu !

If I had seen your question, I would have answered!

elles auraient eu un chien 

is the past conditional 

 

Andrey C.C1Kwiziq community member

Hi Chris! Isn't it "Si je pourrai, j'achèterai une voiture" rather than "Si je peux, j'achèterai une voiture" if we are talking about a situation in the future? Thank you in advance!

CécileNative French expert teacher in Kwiziq

Hi Andrey, 

The car example with a wish is not a good one for the future, here is a better one -

Si je reviens à temps, j'achèterai la voiture = If I come back in time, I'll buy the car

Si je peux, je viendrai vous voir = If I can, I'll come and see you

p.s.

You cannot say 'si je pourrais' in French it will be - 

Si je pouvais, je viendrais vous voir If I could, I would come and see you

In this case 'I could' is a past tense, meaning, if I was able to

Si + present ----> future 

Si + imperfect ----> conditional

Hope this helps! 

CécileNative French expert teacher in Kwiziq

Hi Andrey, 

 

It can only be -

si je peux, j'achèterai une voiture 

si je pouvais, j'achèterais une voiture 

si j'avais pu , j'aurais acheté une voiture 

tony w.C1Kwiziq community member

i have same quesion

tony w.C1Kwiziq community member

i have same quesion

Lee H. asked:

Elles auraient eu un chien si elles avaient pu. Why is it "elles avaient pu " and not " elles auraient pu " Is this not a 'Past conditional "

 Is this phrase  not a   'Past conditional " structure?

Sign in to submit your answer

Don't have an account yet? Join today

Ask a question

Find your French level for FREE

Test your French to the CEFR standard

Find your French level
Let me take a look at that...