My comment relates to English rather than French usage in that I think some non-native English speakers may be confused by the sentence in the second example you give. "Sarah didn't use to trust Thomas" The past participle of "to use" in this case is "used " not "use" although it may be that common America English practice may differ. You could employ "use" to say that "I didn't use the books you suggested" but you would need "used" in front of an infinitive such as "I used to live in London" or "I used to trust you". I refer you to Fowler's Modern English Usage 2nd Ed. p670 where it is pointed out that the modern expression "he used to" replaces an arcane "he uses to". Just to point out that English can be just as exacting as French. Cordialement. K
Use of English?
- « Back to Q&A Forum
- « Previous questionNext question »
Use of English?
In fact "didn't use to" is correct. It changes in the negative because it follows the normal pattern where "didn't" is followed by the infinitive.
https://dictionary.cambridge.org/grammar/british-grammar/used-to
I said I stand corrected. In my defence, however, I quote Fowler ""He didn't use to" should be regarded as an archaism rather than the vulgerism it is thought to be in England though not in US." Just goes to show we only think we speak a common language :-).
From what I can find on the Internet, it seems that edition recommended "he used not to", which is certainly more elegant, and probably sounded less old-fashioned in 1965.
I agree completely.. didn't use to trust looks very odd in UK English.. you might say it but it doesn't scan.. she used to trust him is fine but the negative looks wrong.. what is wrong with she didn't trust him.. anything else seems tautological.
Use of English?
My comment relates to English rather than French usage in that I think some non-native English speakers may be confused by the sentence in the second example you give. "Sarah didn't use to trust Thomas" The past participle of "to use" in this case is "used " not "use" although it may be that common America English practice may differ. You could employ "use" to say that "I didn't use the books you suggested" but you would need "used" in front of an infinitive such as "I used to live in London" or "I used to trust you". I refer you to Fowler's Modern English Usage 2nd Ed. p670 where it is pointed out that the modern expression "he used to" replaces an arcane "he uses to". Just to point out that English can be just as exacting as French. Cordialement. K
Don't have an account yet? Join today
Find your French level for FREE
Test your French to the CEFR standard
Find your French level