Plus-que-parfait avec avoir

BabitA2Kwiziq community member

Plus-que-parfait avec avoir

Voilà deux petites cartes que j'avais achetées.

We do not accord in case of avoir verb as opposed to être in passé composé, but in Plus-que-parfait why have we accorded the 'acheter' verb when with avoir? And does the same happen in case of être as well (in Plus-que-parfait?)

Asked 8 months ago
JimC1 Kwiziq Q&A super contributor Correct answer

Hi Babit,

Your statement "we do not accord in the case of avoir ...." is incorrect.

"Voilà deux petites cartes que j'avais achetées."   

The direct object "cartes" is female and plural and is placed before the verb avoir and therefore requires concordance with the past participle of the verb acheter, therefore achetées.

When the direct object (or its pronoun) appears before the verb with être the same situation is true.

Bonne continuation

Jim

 

Plus-que-parfait avec avoir

Voilà deux petites cartes que j'avais achetées.

We do not accord in case of avoir verb as opposed to être in passé composé, but in Plus-que-parfait why have we accorded the 'acheter' verb when with avoir? And does the same happen in case of être as well (in Plus-que-parfait?)

Sign in to submit your answer

Don't have an account yet? Join today

Ask a question

Find your French level for FREE

Test your French to the CEFR standard

Find your French level
Thinking...