Why is it not "les champignons pointent le bout de leurs nez" to make the possessive adjective plural? I have a French spelling guide that shows "reconnaitrais" with an accent circonflex over the first "i". Which is correct?
Leur - agreement in number/accent in conditional tense
- « Back to Q&A Forum
- « Previous questionNext question »
Leur - agreement in number/accent in conditional tense
So I think the real reason for using the singular here is similar to the following Q&A:
https://kwiziq.learnfrenchwithalexa.com/questions/view/ils-sucent-encore-leur-pouce
Each mushroom points its own "nose". Just a different way of thinking about things in French compared to English.
Bonjour James / Alan,
Thank you for pointing this out, Alan. I agree with you.
‘le bout de leur nez’:
Alan’s explanation is very good indeed. Well done!
Note also that:
Singular ‘leur’:
when only one object is “possessed” by a group of possessors:
Ils aiment leur mère = they love their mother
Ils habitent dans leur manoir en été = they live in their manor in the summer
Plural ‘leurs’:
a. when the possessors have each several of the objects:
Les fermiers vendent leurs vaches = the farmers sell their cows
Les poules s’occupent de leurs poussins = hens take care of their chicks
b. when the noun doesn’t have a singular:
Ils ont cassé leurs lunettes = they broke their spectacles
Ils ont ri à leurs dépens = they laughed at their expense
When every single possessor only possesses one object, it can be in the :
a. singular form = the type of each object instead of the collection of objects:
les hirondelles font leur nid dans les granges = sparrows make their nest in stables
les hommes choisissent leur destin = men choose their destiny
b. plural form = the multitude or the varieties of objects:
les hirondelles font leurs nids de ce côté de la maison = sparrows make their nests on this side of the house
les soldats montrent leurs fusils = the soldiers are showing their rifles
2. The circumflex accent is not compulsory anymore (since a 1990 reform) in verbs ending in -aître. Therefore the correct grammatical spelling is without the circumflex accent although it is still acceptable to use it.
I hope this is helpful.
Bonne journée!
Leur - agreement in number/accent in conditional tense
Why is it not "les champignons pointent le bout de leurs nez" to make the possessive adjective plural? I have a French spelling guide that shows "reconnaitrais" with an accent circonflex over the first "i". Which is correct?
Don't have an account yet? Join today
Find your French level for FREE
Test your French to the CEFR standard
Find your French level