In the Kwiz -
Why is "J'ai dix minutes de retard” correct, and
“Je suis dix minutes en retard”
I know it's simple, but I'm not seeing it.
Different word order required.
Être - Subject/verb/late or early/time period
Avoir - Subject/verb/time period/late or early
With être “ je suis en retard de (dix minutes)”.
English allows changing the word order with ‘to be’ so that we can say “I am 10 minutes early/late” instead of “I am early/late by 10 minutes”. French insists on the latter phrasing with être.
If you think about it “I have 10 minutes” makes some sense but “I have early" doesn’t. On the other hand, “I am early” makes some sense, but “I am 10 minutes” doesn’t. That might help with remembering avoir/être.
(Unfortunately it doesn’t work quite the same with arriver/venir/finir/commencer, but always the exceptions)!
Sometimes it helps me to get into the head of French people and "feel out" how they think about expressing something:
Je suis en retard de dix minutes. -- "I am in delay of 10 minutes."J'ai dix minutes de retard. -- "I have 10 minutes of delay."
Sign in to submit your answer
Don't have an account yet? Join today
Test your French to the CEFR standard