c'est vs il est
- « Back to Q&A Forum
- « Previous questionNext question »
Joakim R.Kwiziq Q&A regular contributor
c'est vs il est
In a writing challenge we had someone describing the new TV they bought: "besides, it's high definition" -> "en plus, elle est haute définition". I'm have from mastered the rules for c'est vs il est, but the one thing I have learned is that when you have a modified noun it's supposed to be "c'est". Yet here we have "haute définition" preceeded by elle est. My best guess is that "haute définition" is to be seen as an expression and should therefore count as an adjective rather than a modified noun ?
Asked 7 years ago
Is it not the case that the previous part of the sentence expressly referred to "la télévision" ?
If so, then the description to follow "haute définition" which, I agree is an adjective describing the television; should make the reference to it as "elle".
I think that "elle" would be more appropriate to use than "c'est" in this context.
Alan
If so, then the description to follow "haute définition" which, I agree is an adjective describing the television; should make the reference to it as "elle".
I think that "elle" would be more appropriate to use than "c'est" in this context.
Alan
Joakim R. asked:View original
c'est vs il est
In a writing challenge we had someone describing the new TV they bought: "besides, it's high definition" -> "en plus, elle est haute définition". I'm have from mastered the rules for c'est vs il est, but the one thing I have learned is that when you have a modified noun it's supposed to be "c'est". Yet here we have "haute définition" preceeded by elle est. My best guess is that "haute définition" is to be seen as an expression and should therefore count as an adjective rather than a modified noun ?
Don't have an account yet? Join today
Ask a question
Find your French level for FREE
Test your French to the CEFR standard
Find your French level